Thanks, Frank - very much appreciated! I'll print them off now...fhimpsl wrote: Hi Peter,
These five pieces should fill the gaps in your collection. Enjoy
Frank

Peter.
Thanks, Frank - very much appreciated! I'll print them off now...fhimpsl wrote: Hi Peter,
These five pieces should fill the gaps in your collection. Enjoy
Frank
Dear Peter,struwwelpeter wrote:Dear Frank,
You very kindly posted a host of Mayerl pieces which I have really enjoyed playing and have plugged several gaps in my collection. You have also been posting some that have not been seen here before, and I would love to know whether you have any more that have not been posted yet.
I (hopefully) attach a list of all the Mayerl that I've collected over the years - if there's anything you have that I don't I'd be very grateful to see it, and equally I'm happy to post anything that other people might not have.
Cheers,
Peter.
Dear Frank,fhimpsl[i] wrote:"Graveyard Blues" is normally found on sheet music and piano rolls as composed by Clarence Woods. However, the first edition of the sheet music credits John S. Caldwell as composer and I don't think it mentions Woods at all. I think this was a collaboration, because Woods was obviously involved. The last strain of "Graveyard Blues" is very similar to the last strain of "Black Satin". And so the ragtime mysteries continue...
All best,
Frank[/i]
gigiranalli wrote:Dear Frank,fhimpsl[i] wrote:"Graveyard Blues" is normally found on sheet music and piano rolls as composed by Clarence Woods. However, the first edition of the sheet music credits John S. Caldwell as composer and I don't think it mentions Woods at all. I think this was a collaboration, because Woods was obviously involved. The last strain of "Graveyard Blues" is very similar to the last strain of "Black Satin". And so the ragtime mysteries continue...
All best,
Frank[/i]
I didn't know about this issue about the acknowledgement for "Graveyard Blues". That's very interesting!
It makes me think to another piece with a similar story, the "Jinx Rag".
That was originally composed by Jesse Dukes and Lucian Porter Gibson and published by Gibson in 1911.
Than John Stark published a later version of the piece in 1915, arranged by Artie Matthews, and the name of Jesse Dukes simply disappeared....
While the Stark version, arranged by Matthews, is very common (it's also foundable on internet: http://digital.library.msstate.edu/cgi- ... =23933.pdf ), the original version from 1911 is quite rare. I have a deep, a very strong distaste for two particular musicians of the ragtime age, one is Scott Joplin and the other is Artie Matthews, so this may have to do with the fact that I definitely prefer the original version of Jinx Rag than the 1915 arrangement. I admit that the second strain in the Matthews version is better, but I think that he spoiled the first strain, whose original version sounds stronger, more idiosyncratic and less repetitive to me.
Also, I'm very jealous about this particular piece (the 1911 version, of course!), but I'm pleased to share it with Pianophilia!!
I hope you all enjoy this rare and eccentric rag![]()
Best RAGards
Luigi
Here you go, Luigi! Not my scan...gigiranalli wrote: Dear Peter,
I checked your Mayerl list and found a piece that I'd been looking for, that is his arrangement of "If You Knew Susie".
When you have time, could you please post it on Pianophilia? I'm always looking for interesting arrangements of popular numbers.
Thanks and regards
Luigi
Hi Peter,struwwelpeter wrote:Here you go, Luigi! Not my scan...
Cheers,
Peter.
Dear Frank,fhimpsl wrote: Even worse, there were complete thefts of the material as well. One of the best known rags there is, "12th Street Rag", was lifted outright by Euday Bowman from a ca. 1912 rag published in St. Louis and entitled "The Candy Rag" by Robert Bircher. The comparison to 12th St. is not a remote one....it is doggone note-for-note the same piece. I could give even more examples, but they raise my blood pressure in discussing them!!