French Piano Music

alfor · Post by **alfor** » Wed Sep 30, 2015 4:59 pm

Rameau-Huber
or
Huber-Rameau
?

Rameau-Huber Suite 2.pdf

alfor · Post by **alfor** » Wed Sep 30, 2015 10:13 pm

...amazing...

Is this Ravel's Sonatina...pdf

fleubis · Post by **fleubis** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 1:11 am

Dear Alfred, Am greatly enjoying the Rameau-Huber....nice arrangements and I especially like the realization of the ornaments--I'm certainly not up to speed on French Baroque ornamentation and probably will never find the time.

I would say that Ravel simulation is an abomination, better left in the dustbin.

alfor · Post by **alfor** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 9:28 am

fleubis wrote:I would say that Ravel simulation is an abomination, better left in the dustbin.

I certainly agree...but it nevertheless is amazing that he achieves about 90% of the original sound!
He also did Gaspard...in that case I think I can do without it!

soh choon wee · Post by **soh choon wee** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 3:17 pm

alfor wrote:
fleubis wrote:I would say that Ravel simulation is an abomination, better left in the dustbin.
I certainly agree...but it nevertheless is amazing that he achieves about 90% of the original sound!
He also did Gaspard...in that case I think I can do without it!

OH please let me see the Gaspard.
That is an impossible piece.... I wonder what can scarbo be reduced into.....

alfor · Post by **alfor** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 4:44 pm

http://www.jwpepper.com/10376839E.item#.Vg1hU2rFf1Q

Sorry, no preview!

soh choon wee · Post by **soh choon wee** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 4:57 pm

alfor wrote:http://www.jwpepper.com/10376839E.item#.Vg1hU2rFf1Q

Sorry, no preview!

There is an audio clip........ I listen for 2 minutes..... no I don't want to see the score anymore.

This man murdered Ravel.

fleubis · Post by **fleubis** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 5:30 pm

While I have no quarrel with some simplified versions of the classics for beginning pianists to get their fingers into some famous themes, but this kind of re-writing is beyond the pale. You don't rewrite Ravel's masterpieces. Difficult? Definitely, but we all know how you get to Carnegie Hall, etc...

Ferruccio · Post by **Ferruccio** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 8:18 pm

alfor wrote:...amazing...

Is this Ravel's Sonatina...pdf

Argghhh !!!
Horrible text!!

alfor · Post by **alfor** » Thu Oct 01, 2015 8:40 pm

Ferruccio wrote:
alfor wrote:...amazing...

Is this Ravel's Sonatina...pdf

Argghhh !!!
Horrible text!!

Wenn es Dir Vergnügen bereitet:
Bomiers Fassung der Valses nobles ist ebenfalls komplett als Preview einzusehen

...

Admittedly I prefer the other way round: i.e. „Godowskyfying“ or „Sorabjifying“...

P.S. Bomiers recording of Scarbo is simply a midi-version. As I could
detect from the first minutes it is a very slow version of the original score.

Pianophilia

French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music

Re: French Piano Music