Re: School of Syncopation - Jazz, Stride, Novelties & the Like.
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2011 1:46 am
Frank,
Thank you as ever for the postings and the missing Mayerl.
Please, Frank, speaking for myself there is really no need to rush in to tackling the Mayerl transcriptions and it wasn't my intention to "push" you into that in preference over your current plans.
Since you had stated a future intention to deal with Mayerl at some point in the future I was just hoping to assist in bringing the main works of Mayerl up to near completion thereby saving you scanning time in the future.
Personally, I'm thoroughly enjoying the postings you are currently embarked on and I wouldn't want to deflect you from continuing that project. In fact I'm sure all of us in this forum would encourage you to continue.
It seems unfair that you should be doing all the work, however - so I was thinking that if those of us who had outstanding Mayerl transcriptions or other works which haven't been previously posted could post them up contemporaneously with your current project, it would become clearer what is actually outstanding. That way, if you still wish to post up the Mayerl balance in the future (and I'm sure you have them all anyway - since your collection so far has proved astonishingly complete) the scanning burden should then be a little less daunting.
Whatever you post has already been fantastic and I'm sure will continue to be - my Mayerl postings were not intended to influence a change in your preferred schedule.
I post up here a text file of what Mayerl I think has already been posted in this forum (not including this page (66)). If my proposal commends itself to you Frank, then would-be posters of outstanding Mayerl works (transcriptions / arrangements) can easily see whether they have anything in their own collections to contribute. With luck your own Mayerl scans will become a far less daunting task.
This text file is in alphabetical (not chronological order).
If anyone is interested I have a similar file for ALL the postings on the forum (excluding audio files). Best Wishes,
tobyjj
Thank you as ever for the postings and the missing Mayerl.
Please, Frank, speaking for myself there is really no need to rush in to tackling the Mayerl transcriptions and it wasn't my intention to "push" you into that in preference over your current plans.
Since you had stated a future intention to deal with Mayerl at some point in the future I was just hoping to assist in bringing the main works of Mayerl up to near completion thereby saving you scanning time in the future.
Personally, I'm thoroughly enjoying the postings you are currently embarked on and I wouldn't want to deflect you from continuing that project. In fact I'm sure all of us in this forum would encourage you to continue.
It seems unfair that you should be doing all the work, however - so I was thinking that if those of us who had outstanding Mayerl transcriptions or other works which haven't been previously posted could post them up contemporaneously with your current project, it would become clearer what is actually outstanding. That way, if you still wish to post up the Mayerl balance in the future (and I'm sure you have them all anyway - since your collection so far has proved astonishingly complete) the scanning burden should then be a little less daunting.
Whatever you post has already been fantastic and I'm sure will continue to be - my Mayerl postings were not intended to influence a change in your preferred schedule.
I post up here a text file of what Mayerl I think has already been posted in this forum (not including this page (66)). If my proposal commends itself to you Frank, then would-be posters of outstanding Mayerl works (transcriptions / arrangements) can easily see whether they have anything in their own collections to contribute. With luck your own Mayerl scans will become a far less daunting task.
This text file is in alphabetical (not chronological order).
If anyone is interested I have a similar file for ALL the postings on the forum (excluding audio files). Best Wishes,
tobyjj