Pianophilia

Mouchette wrote:

phikfy wrote:Before, I posted the Mountain King and Alfor posted the Morning Mood. Now here comes the remaining two movements which finally complete the whole set.
Enjoy!
Koon

Thanks! But it's strange: the text is exactly the same than Grieg's own transcription. Same typography too. Are you sure that Ginzburg did it?

I just double checked mine against the Grieg transcription on the IMSLP and they are different. My source is from Qnote. I think they should be honest. And I checked the first piece (Morning Mood) against Alfor's post before and they are just the same. Therefore, by inference, I may conclude that my copy is a Ginzburg arrangement. The Mountain King is what we heard from Matusev. My humble opinion only, though...

Best,
Koon

phikfy wrote:

Mouchette wrote:

phikfy wrote:Before, I posted the Mountain King and Alfor posted the Morning Mood. Now here comes the remaining two movements which finally complete the whole set.
Enjoy!
Koon

Thanks! But it's strange: the text is exactly the same than Grieg's own transcription. Same typography too. Are you sure that Ginzburg did it?

I just double checked mine against the Grieg transcription on the IMSLP and they are different. My source is from Qnote. I think they should be honest. And I checked the first piece (Morning Mood) against Alfor's post before and they are just the same. Therefore, by inference, I may conclude that my copy is a Ginzburg arrangement. The Mountain King is what we heard from Matusev. My humble opinion only, though...

Best,
Koon

My Grieg/Grieg score (the same than your Grieg/Ginzburg) comes from "CD sheet music". We have to choose which one is dishonest...
Yours,
M.

Mouchette wrote:

phikfy wrote:

Mouchette wrote:

phikfy wrote:Before, I posted the Mountain King and Alfor posted the Morning Mood. Now here comes the remaining two movements which finally complete the whole set.
Enjoy!
Koon

Thanks! But it's strange: the text is exactly the same than Grieg's own transcription. Same typography too. Are you sure that Ginzburg did it?

I just double checked mine against the Grieg transcription on the IMSLP and they are different. My source is from Qnote. I think they should be honest. And I checked the first piece (Morning Mood) against Alfor's post before and they are just the same. Therefore, by inference, I may conclude that my copy is a Ginzburg arrangement. The Mountain King is what we heard from Matusev. My humble opinion only, though...

Best,
Koon

My Grieg/Grieg score (the same than your Grieg/Ginzburg) comes from "CD sheet music". We have to choose which one is dishonest...
Yours,
M.

You can just check against the one posted on IMSLP. Perhaps the one that you had from CD sheet music is actually a Ginzburg version. To be honest, I think Grieg himself wouldn't write like the way on my copy. His pianism should look a bit simpler.

Yours,
Koon

I've combined all in one pdf. Many thanks to Alfor and phikfy for they scans!
So is this a Grigory Ginzburg transcription or not??


Again many kudos to Alfor and phikfy.

Thank you Aggelos for this and also the other thing,
if you get my drift.

Timtin wrote:Thank you Aggelos for this and also the other thing,
if you get my drift.

Yes I've got your drift.
Cheers

Does anyone have Kamenski's transcription of Mussorgsky's 3 Pieces form Boris Godunov?
I just heard them for the first time here:
http://www.youtube.com/profile?user=Bec ... T_1LGX6uac

THANKS!!

Anyone have the transcription of the Polka from Dances of the Dolls by Shostakovitch?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8QSJtgF-2M

THANKS!!

Nice music, indeed! NMS - TTTOS:

The original version of this short song is on IMSLP.
For Mozza, it was all in a day's work!
This piano arrangement was probably by Alfred Moffat.
(Die Verschweigung = The Concealment.)